f you think that Supreme Court rulings are dull, technical, and remote from the world as it is, 5-4 is going to surprise you. 

Peter, Michael, and Rhiannon host this podcast, which has a bold, probing, and often amusing discussion of landmark Supreme Court cases, uncovering how law and politics collide to shape society.

Unlike other law podcasts that just regurgitate decisions, 5-4 informs you of the truth and how it’s impacting people, how these decisions actually do, who wins, and who doesn’t. 

It's sarcastic, witty, and isn't afraid to call out the Supreme Court on its worst decisions. That’s why you will get addicted pretty quickly, as I did.

Most law podcasts try to be neutral; 5-4 does not. The hosts have a clear point of view: the Supreme Court is a political institution, and its rulings generally serve the powerful at the expense of regular people. 

They provide a mix of trenchant analysis, dark humor, and historical context to dissect cases in an entertaining, engaging, and brutally honest way.

Expect:

• Deep dives into prominent Supreme Court cases—recent and historical.

• Strong, unflinching examination of court decisions that shape America.

• Much humor and personality brought to the subject of the law—legal discourse rendered enjoyable to listen to.

What sets this podcast apart is not your typical lawcast: strong opinions, humor, and cultural background, not dry explication of the law.

It deconstructs how the Supreme Court are rulings for the rest of us; how they impact voters, workers, corporations, and democracy.

You’ll hear great personalities, thorough knowledge of the law, explaining in plain English.

They're not just covering Supreme Court rulings; they're analyzing them, dispelling judicial illusions of neutrality, and showing how politics and power shape law.

Who Does This Podcast Address?

This show is for you if you:

• Want to know what the Supreme Court actually does, without all the law jargon.

• Like snappy, irreverent humor mixed with incisive analysis.

• Are annoyed at how courts ruled in favor of corporations, elites, and special interests, instead of ordinary people.

Episodes We Loved

1. Jan 21, 2025: Murphy v. NCAA

2. Feb 25, 2025: McCutcheon v. FEC

3. Feb 25, 2025: McCutcheon v. FEC

When & Where to Listen

New episodes of 5-4 drop every week, and you can listen to the show on PodcastAI Chart,  Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and other major platforms.

Don’t forget to visit the official website, and if you’re an X fan, here is where to find the show’s account.

Who are the hosts?

Peter, Michael, and Rhiannon are lawyers who clearly know the law, but they bring a comfortable, informal touch to the show that keeps the program from feeling like a sermon and instead a conversation. 

They are adept at balancing humor, analysis, and practical applicability, making 5-4 one of the most enjoyable and informative legal podcasts out there.

You May Also Like

If you enjoy 5-4, check out these other incisive and insightful legal podcasts:

Strict Scrutiny, where constitutional law scholars break down Supreme Court cases and how they have broader implications. Read our review here!

The Lawfare Podcast, on national security, government policy, and law's place in democracy. Our review is here!

The Young Turks, with liberal observations on law, politics, and the news with sharp wit. Find our review here!

The Takeaway

5-4 is mandatory listening for anyone who would like a critical, thoughtful, and occasionally humorous analysis of the Supreme Court. 

If you are tired of the law being used so often to preserve power instead of justice, this podcast will give you the information, context, and biting commentary you can't find anywhere else.

For smart-quick, no-BS legal analysis with personality and humor, 5-4 is required listening.

Looking for more podcasts to listen to?

We got you covered!

Top Fashion and Beauty Podcasts to Inspire Your Style in 2025

The Funniest Comedy Podcasts to Listen to in 2025

Top TV & Film Podcasts of 2025: Behind-the-Scenes, Celebrities & Fun

Best News Podcasts 2025: Your Essential Guide to Keep Informed

Top 15 Music Podcasts in 2025: All The Shows You Cannot Miss!

17 Best Art Podcasts You’ll Love in 2025: Design, Culture, & More

The Best ASMR Podcasts of 2025: Ultimate Guide to Relaxation & Tingles

Top Erotica Podcasts of 2025: Best Reviews!

Top Crime Podcasts of 2025: Thrills, Chills, and True Fear

40 Apple Podcasts That Talk About Books: Your Next Literary Listen

Top Educational Podcasts 2025: Learn Something New Every Day

Best Tech Podcasts to Start the Year (2025)

12 Government and Politics Podcasts you cannot miss in 2025

For Podcast lovers only!

Are you a podcast enthusiast who doesn’t want to miss out on the best shows of the moment? Discover them all on PodcastAI Chart! Explore the top podcasts from around the world in a single chart, with daily ranking updates and historical data. Check them out now!

Author's note

Have you ever wanted to create a podcast but didn’t have the time or resources? PodcastAI is here to make that dream come true.

With our AI-powered software, you can easily transform your blog posts, newsletters, or favorite news articles into podcast episodes—using your own voice, with almost no effort.

PodcastAI handles every detail: it writes episodes, generates show notes, creates eye-catching cover art, and adds chapters and transcripts.

It even automatically publishes your podcast to Apple, Spotify, and other platforms, while also providing social media clips and a custom website for your show.

Whether you're a content creator, business owner, or agency, PodcastAI saves you time and helps you connect with your audience in a whole new way.